Total Loss

Totaled vehicles and settlements

Settled my total loss claim with Progressive for $9,400 over the initial offer on a 2021 Toyota Tacoma by challenging the comparable vehicle valuations one by one. Here is the exact spreadsheet method I used and the comparables that moved the needle

Sharing this because total loss valuations are one of the most under-disputed areas in auto claims. Background: I am in suburban Atlanta. In February 2026 my 2021 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road double cab...

Posted by confusedHomeowner197